Your Cart

Free shipping on contiguous US orders!

Your cart is empty

ICO vs pHin
ICO from $449 Buy ICO
Pool water monitor comparison

ICO vs pHin

pHin was Hayward's floating monitor, sold with a subscription and cloud service. Hayward ended the service on December 20, 2021, and the monitor has not provided active chemistry readings since then. ICO is a current alternative with direct Wi-Fi, hourly readings, no subscription, and owner-replaceable sensors.

Hayward's shutdown notice gives December 20, 2021 as the end of pHin service. The monitor no longer measures chemistry.
Our pick
ICO Pool smart water monitor by Ondilo

ICO Pool

List price $449 Chlorine / bromine · Salt $499
Water readings Every hour Active product with a free app
Discontinued
pHin smart water monitor (discontinued)

pHin Smart Water Monitor

Current status Discontinued Service ended December 20, 2021
Water readings None App and cloud service shut down

At a glance

Compare the 16 everyday ownership details that separate these monitors. Green means included, red means not included, and amber means limited or conditional.

ICO Pool
pHin
No required subscription
Service ended
No refill cassettes or testing reagents
Subscription-based
Connects directly to Wi-Fi
Cloud service shut down
Bluetooth for setup and nearby access
No longer functions
Tracks pH
No longer functions
Tracks sanitizer performance (ORP)
No longer functions
Tracks water temperature
No longer functions
Measures salt and TDS
ICO Salt
Checks the water at least once an hour
Uses a rechargeable battery
Sensors can be replaced individually
Replacement parts have public prices
Discontinued
Supports chlorine, bromine, and salt pools
App includes alerts and treatment guidance
App shut down
Can float or sit in the skimmer
No longer functions
Available in the U.S. with support
Discontinued December 20, 2021
Our pick
ICO Pool
—

Side-by-side specs

Compare testing frequency, price, ongoing costs, warranty, battery, replacement parts, and measurements.

Specification ICO Pool pHin Smart Water Monitor
Price $449 for Chlorine/Bromine · $499 for Salt Discontinued · do not buy old stock
Subscription or service fee No subscription or annual app fee Service ended December 20, 2021
Consumables No cassettes, test pads, or reagents —
What it measures pH, ORP (sanitizer performance), and temperature · ICO Salt adds salt and TDS No current measurements · the monitor no longer functions
Reading frequency Every hour, 24/7 —
Connection Direct 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi and Bluetooth · no hub or gateway Cloud-dependent · servers shut down
Power and battery Built-in battery recharges over USB · 6+ months per charge —
Warranty 1-year manufacturer warranty None — product discontinued
Replacement parts pH, ORP, and TDS sensors sold individually ($149 each) · Smart Core $279 None available
Expected sensor life pH and ORP: 2–4 years · TDS: 5–6 years (manufacturer estimates) —
Calibration Once at the start of each season, or every 6 months for year-round use · $49 kit —
Installation Floats in the pool or sits in the skimmer —
Pool types Chlorine, bromine, and salt · in-ground pools, above-ground pools, and spas —

What happened to pHin?

A Hayward shutdown letter, reproduced by dealers after the original page was removed, states that pHin service ended on December 20, 2021. Because pHin's readings and recommendations lived in Hayward's cloud, every monitor stopped actively measuring chemistry on that date. Hayward no longer supports the product, and there is no current parts channel.

How ICO reduces the same lock-in risk

ICO connects to your own 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, its app has no paid subscription, and it does not use test cartridges. Its pH, ORP, and TDS probes are standard electrochemical sensors sold for $149 each, have multi-year manufacturer life estimates, and are replaceable by the owner. Ondilo has shipped ICO since 2017, and MySmartPool provides U.S. support and a 30-day guarantee.

Cost of ownership after pHin

pHin required a subscription, while ICO does not. ICO costs $449 for the Chlorine/Bromine model or $499 for the Salt model. After purchase, ongoing costs are about $49 per season for a calibration kit and, every few years, whichever sensor needs replacement.

What ICO measures

ICO reads pH, ORP (sanitizer performance), and temperature every hour, while ICO Salt adds conductivity-based salt and TDS readings. Its free app provides alerts, trends, weather context, and plain-language dosing advice.

Our recommendation

So, which is better: ICO or pHin?

In our opinion, ICO is the clear winner because it is an active product with hourly readings, no required subscription, and owner-replaceable sensors. Hayward ended pHin service on December 20, 2021, so pHin units no longer provide active chemistry readings.

Why ICO is our pick

ICO connects directly to Wi-Fi, records hourly readings, and lets owners replace individual probes as they age.

Current pHin status

pHin hardware depends on Hayward's discontinued cloud service. Units offered as leftover inventory cannot provide current chemistry readings.

Why ICO comes out ahead

  • No subscription or paid app plan
  • Hourly pH, ORP, and temperature; salt on the Salt model
  • Individually replaceable $149 sensors from U.S. stock
  • Direct Wi-Fi plus Bluetooth; floats or sits in the skimmer

Price and availability

ICO Pool is available directly from MySmartPool with free shipping, a 30-day guarantee, and U.S. support. The competing model is included for a balanced comparison, but MySmartPool does not sell it.

ICO Pool smart water monitor
Our pick

ICO Pool

No subscription. No cassettes. Ships free from Texas.

ICO Pool — Chlorine / Bromine

$449In stock

ICO Pool — Salt

$499In stock
  • Free shipping
  • 30-day guarantee
  • 1-year warranty
  • No subscription, ever
Full ICO Pool details →

pHin Smart Water Monitor

  • List priceDiscontinued — service ended December 20, 2021. Do not buy old stock.
  • TestingNo readings — Service ended December 20, 2021
  • AvailabilityDiscontinued

MySmartPool does not currently sell pHin.

Common questions

Does pHin still work?

No. Hayward's shutdown notice gives December 20, 2021 as the end of pHin service; the monitor no longer actively measures chemistry.

What can replace pHin?

ICO Pool is one current option. It has no required subscription, connects directly to Wi-Fi, reads pH, ORP, and temperature hourly, adds salt and TDS on ICO Salt, and uses owner-replaceable sensors.

How does ICO reduce the cloud-lock-in risk seen with pHin?

ICO has no paid cloud plan, and its standard probes are replaceable retail parts. Ondilo has sold ICO since 2017, and MySmartPool stocks the monitor and its sensors in the U.S.

More comparisons

See how ICO compares with other smart pool water monitors.

See every pool monitor side by side →