Your Cart

Free shipping on contiguous US orders!

Your cart is empty

ICO vs WaterGuru SENSE S3
ICO from $449 Buy ICO
Pool water monitor comparison

ICO vs WaterGuru SENSE S3

ICO monitors your water automatically every hour, while WaterGuru runs one scheduled cassette test each day. Compare their prices, ongoing costs, measurements, installation, and replacement parts.

Our pick
ICO Pool smart water monitor by Ondilo

ICO Pool

List price $449 Chlorine / bromine · Salt $499
Testing schedule Every hour 24 automatic readings each day
WaterGuru SENSE S3 smart pool monitor

WaterGuru SENSE S3

List price $399 Includes one C5+ cassette
Testing schedule Once daily 1 scheduled chemistry test each day

At a glance

Compare the 16 everyday ownership details that separate these monitors. Green means included, red means not included, and amber means limited or conditional.

ICO Pool
WaterGuru S3
No required subscription
The app is free
No refill cassettes or testing reagents
A 3-pack of cassettes costs $76
Connects directly to Wi-Fi
Bluetooth for setup and nearby access
For setup and nearby use only
Tracks pH
Tracks sanitizer performance (ORP)
Tracks water temperature
Measures salt and TDS
ICO Salt
Salt-compatible; does not measure salt
Checks the water at least once an hour
One scheduled test per day
Uses a rechargeable battery
Solar charging; USB-C backup
Sensors can be replaced individually
Hardware service requires support
Replacement parts have public prices
Public prices only for cassettes and adapters
Supports chlorine, bromine, and salt pools
Bromine enabled in the app
App includes alerts and treatment guidance
Can float or sit in the skimmer
Skimmer-mounted; optional float ring is $29
Available in the U.S. with support
Our pick
ICO Pool
—

Side-by-side specs

Compare testing frequency, price, ongoing costs, warranty, battery, replacement parts, and measurements.

Specification ICO Pool WaterGuru SENSE S3
Price $449 for Chlorine/Bromine · $499 for Salt $399 list price · includes one C5+ cassette
Subscription or service fee No subscription or annual app fee No app fee, but cassettes are required for testing
Consumables No cassettes, test pads, or reagents C5+ cassette: 32 daily tests · C2+ cassette: 64 tests · 3-pack costs $76 (about $289 per year for daily C5+ testing)
What it measures pH, ORP (sanitizer performance), and temperature · ICO Salt adds salt and TDS C5+: free chlorine, pH, alkalinity, CYA, and calcium hardness · also measures temperature and flow · no ORP or salt measurement
Reading frequency Every hour, 24/7 One scheduled chemistry test per day · each additional test uses another cassette pad
Connection Direct 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi and Bluetooth · no hub or gateway Direct 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi · Bluetooth for setup and nearby testing
Power and battery Built-in battery recharges over USB · 6+ months per charge Solar charging with USB-C backup · support estimates about 5 months in full shade; the product page says 9 months
Warranty 1-year manufacturer warranty 1-year hardware warranty · cassette defects covered, normal depletion is not
Replacement parts pH, ORP, and TDS sensors sold individually ($149 each) · Smart Core $279 Cassettes, skimmer adapters ($29), a float ring ($29), and a mesh bag · no user-replaceable electronics or battery verified
Expected sensor life pH and ORP: 2–4 years · TDS: 5–6 years (manufacturer estimates) Per cassette: 32 or 64 tests · more frequent testing shortens calendar life
Calibration Once at the start of each season, or every 6 months for year-round use · $49 kit No user calibration required · replace cassettes and keep the sensing area clean
Installation Floats in the pool or sits in the skimmer Sits in a standard 8-inch skimmer · adapters or float ring sold separately
Pool types Chlorine, bromine, and salt · in-ground pools, above-ground pools, and spas Chlorine and bromine (through an app setting) · compatible with salt levels up to 5,000 ppm but does not measure salt

Price and ongoing cost: ICO vs WaterGuru SENSE S3

WaterGuru has the lower list price at $399, compared with $449 for ICO Pool (Chlorine/Bromine) or $499 for ICO Salt. The important difference is what happens after checkout. A C5+ cassette covers 32 daily tests, and a 3-pack costs $76. Testing once a day works out to roughly $289 a year with C5+ cassettes, or about $144 with the two-value C2+ version.

ICO does not use cassettes, pads, or reagents, and the app has no annual fee. Routine costs include a $49 calibration kit at the start of each season and, after several years, whichever individual sensor needs replacing.

Warranty: ICO vs WaterGuru

Both monitors include a one-year manufacturer warranty. WaterGuru covers the SENSE S3 hardware and manufacturing defects in its cassettes; normal cassette use is not covered. ICO also carries a one-year warranty, and its pH, ORP, and TDS probes are separate parts that owners can replace when they eventually wear out.

Replacement parts and sensor life

WaterGuru sells cassettes, skimmer adapters, a float ring, and a mesh bag. We could not verify a user-replaceable battery or electronics module for the S3, so out-of-warranty hardware service begins with WaterGuru support.

ICO uses individually replaceable probes. The pH sensor, ORP sensor and TDS sensor each sell for $149, while the Smart Core electronics module is $279. Ondilo estimates 2–4 years for the pH and ORP probes and 5–6 years for the TDS probe.

Battery life and charging

WaterGuru charges from a solar panel with USB-C backup. Support estimates about 5 months on a full charge in total shade, and roughly an hour of direct sun per day keeps one daily test going. The product page separately advertises 9 months without sun; we use the more conservative support figure.

ICO's built-in lithium battery is rated for 6+ months per USB charge, regardless of sunlight. Seasonal owners typically charge it when opening the pool; year-round owners charge it about twice a year. Let the unit dry for 12 hours before opening the charging port, then allow around 10 hours for a full charge.

What each monitor measures

WaterGuru's C5+ cassette measures free chlorine, pH, total alkalinity, cyanuric acid, and calcium hardness once each day. The C2+ cassette measures free chlorine and pH. WaterGuru does not include an ORP or salt sensor; it can be used in salt pools up to 5,000 ppm, but it does not report the salt level.

ICO measures pH, ORP, and temperature every hour, while ICO Salt also measures salt and TDS through conductivity. ORP shows how effectively the sanitizer is working, allowing ICO to build a 24-reading daily trend without consuming a test pad.

Wi-Fi, app and installation

Both connect directly to 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi with no gateway, and both offer free iOS and Android apps with alerts and dosing advice. WaterGuru mounts in a standard 8-inch skimmer; other skimmer shapes require a $29 adapter, while floating it in the pool requires the optional $29 float ring.

ICO floats on its own or sits in the skimmer out of the box. It stores the last 42 hours of readings during a Wi-Fi outage, and its free app supports shared access and multiple pools.

Maintenance and calibration

WaterGuru requires no user calibration because each cassette provides a fresh set of test pads. Maintenance consists of replacing cassettes and keeping the sensing area clean. ICO requires a quick two-point calibration at the start of each season (every 6 months for year-round use) with a $49 kit, and its probes must stay moist in storage.

Our recommendation

So, which is better: ICO or WaterGuru?

In our opinion, ICO is the clear winner for most residential pools based on its 24 automatic readings per day, cassette-free operation, and individually replaceable sensors. WaterGuru's direct free-chlorine test remains a meaningful advantage for owners who prioritize that single daily result.

Why ICO is our pick

ICO checks pH, ORP, and temperature every hour, works in the pool or skimmer, and lets owners replace each sensor separately when it eventually wears out.

Where WaterGuru may be the better fit

WaterGuru directly measures free chlorine once per day. Buyers who prioritize that measurement over hourly ORP trends and cassette-free testing may prefer it.

Why ICO comes out ahead

  • 24 automatic readings a day with no test pads
  • $0 annual app fee and no refill cassettes
  • ICO Salt reports the salt level, not just salt-pool compatibility
  • Individually replaceable pH, ORP, and TDS sensors

Price and availability

ICO Pool is available directly from MySmartPool with free shipping, a 30-day guarantee, and U.S. support. The competing model is included for a balanced comparison, but MySmartPool does not sell it.

ICO Pool smart water monitor
Our pick

ICO Pool

No subscription. No cassettes. Ships free from Texas.

ICO Pool — Chlorine / Bromine

$449In stock

ICO Pool — Salt

$499In stock
  • Free shipping
  • 30-day guarantee
  • 1-year warranty
  • No subscription, ever
Full ICO Pool details →

WaterGuru SENSE S3

  • List price$399 with one C5+ cassette included
  • TestingOnce daily — Scheduled cassette-based chemistry test
  • AvailabilityAvailable in the U.S.

MySmartPool does not currently sell WaterGuru S3.

Common questions

Is the WaterGuru SENSE S3 better than ICO?

WaterGuru measures free chlorine once a day. ICO measures pH, ORP, and temperature every hour, adds salt and TDS on the Salt model, and does not require refill cassettes. WaterGuru suits owners who prioritize a daily chlorine result; ICO is our pick for frequent monitoring and lower ongoing costs.

Does WaterGuru have a subscription?

There is no app subscription, but the SENSE S3 cannot test without refill cassettes. A 3-pack costs $76 and covers about 96 daily C5+ tests, so daily testing costs roughly $289 per year. ICO has no subscription and no consumables.

How does the WaterGuru warranty compare to ICO?

Both carry a one-year hardware warranty. WaterGuru also covers manufacturing defects in cassettes but not normal depletion. ICO's sensors are user-replaceable retail parts, so an aging probe is a $149 swap rather than a service ticket.

Can WaterGuru measure salt?

No. WaterGuru is compatible with salt pools up to 5,000 ppm but does not measure salt concentration. ICO Salt measures salt and TDS via conductivity every hour.

How long does the WaterGuru battery last compared to ICO?

WaterGuru support estimates about 5 months on a full charge in shade, extended by its solar panel. ICO's rechargeable battery is rated for 6+ months per charge with no dependence on sunlight.

More comparisons

See how ICO compares with other smart pool water monitors.

See every pool monitor side by side →